Why Is Judge Judy So Mean? (8 Reasons Why)

Photo of author
Freya Crawford

Freya Crawford is a self-confessed geek. She loves gaming, watching classic movies, and her guilty pleasure is trashy reality TV. She also enjoys collecting old NES and Gameboy games.

Judge Judy Sheindlin is one of the most popular daytime television personalities. But, unfortunately, she’s also one of the most controversial.

Many people accuse her of being needlessly rude to the litigants on her show, and former show employees can attest to her meanness.

Why Is Judge Judy So Mean?

1. Time As A Judge

Judge Judy has been a TV judge for over 20 years. She’s seen a lot of cases, and she’s heard a lot of sob stories. But, she is not get swayed by emotions or sentimentality.

She sticks to the facts and the law. Unfortunately, Sheindlin has handled thousands of cases and appears to have grown callous.

During her time on television, Judge Judy has shown no sympathy for litigants’ problems and challenges, and she comes across as mean.

2. Doesn’t Take Crap

Judge Judy has zero tolerance for B.S. She’s not afraid to speak her mind, and she’s not afraid to call people out when they’re wrong or lying.

She wants everyone to know that she’s in charge and will not tolerate any nonsense. Judge Judy is known for being very tough on people who break the law or try to lie in court.

Judge Judy is mean because she expects people to live up to her high standards. She expects people to be honest, respectful, and polite, even if she’s not.

If staff falls short of her expectations, she can be critical and rude. The staff has reported harassment and abuse from Sheindlin during their time working for the show.

Read More:  Why Do Celebrities Wear Sunglasses Indoors? (7 Reasons Why)

3. Quick And To The Point

Judge Judy is quick-witted and to the point. She doesn’t waste time with small talk or frivolous arguments. Instead, she gets straight to the heart of the matter and makes her decisions quickly.

Sheindlin’s no-nonsense approach is one of the reasons she’s so popular, but also a reason she has gained the reputation of being mean.

Judge Judy is known for her sharp tongue. She’s not afraid to speak her mind and often delivers scathing remarks to those who cross her.

She is known for being tough on defendants. This uncompromising stance is one of the reasons why she’s so popular and regarded as mean.

4. Drunk On Set

Drunk On Set

According to former staff, Judge Judy may drink on set, as evidenced by some of her bizarre behavior while filming.

Judy seems a bit “off” in some episodes, and her alcohol consumption while filming may make her more likely to lash out at people and be rude to them.

Judge Judy may be drunk on set, and with her bad temper, she says things that are hurtful or cruel to people.

5. No Patience

Judge Judy is often impatient and seems mean when she is just trying to move things along.

Judge Judy is known for her no-nonsense attitude and lack of patience. She is often abrupt and abrasive when someone does not get to the point.

Read More:  Why Do People Care About Celebrities? (11 Reasons Why)

She hates it when people try to waste her time or when they don’t take her court seriously. So she loses her temper and shouts at people who are not serious about their case.

Judge Judy doesn’t hesitate to interrupt someone if she feels they are not making a valid point, and she is also quick to anger if someone doe not answers her questions directly.

6. Opinionated

Judge Judy is also very opinionated and holds firm opinions on many topics, including the cases that come before her in court.

She will often make her opinions known without giving the other side a chance to speak, frustrating for people trying to have a fair, balanced discussion.

She will raise her voice and get angry if someone says something she disagrees with. She does not have patience for disagreements.

7. Rude And Arrogant

Judge Judy is often perceived as rude and arrogant because she is so straight forward with people and doesn’t hesitate to point out their mistakes.

Sheindlin has a very abrasive personality, and her arrogance combined with personal attributes contributes to her reputation for being a mean person.

She also has a very strong personality, which can come across as mean. Judge Judy may seem mean because she often deals with people in difficult situations.

As a result, Judge Judy may seem like she is being tough on them when she is just trying to get to the bottom of the case.

Read More:  Why Is Megan Fox So Famous? (11 Reasons Why)

8. Argumentative Character

Finally, it is important to remember that Judge Judy is a television character. She is not a real judge, and her show is not an actual courtroom.

She can be way more belligerent towards litigants and come across as if she is looking to argue with them. Instead, she looks for reasons they are wrong or lying.

Without attorneys, litigants on the show are forced to answer Judge Judy’s questions, so essentially, she is acting as a lawyer questioning litigants and the judge deciding the case.

Judge Judy is allowed to be more theatrical than a real judge, so she can be more forceful with her rulings and more outspoken in her questioning of witnesses.

To learn more, you can also read our posts on why Mr. Beast is so popular, why Kim Kardashian is famous, and why people hate Jeff Bezos.


All in all, Judith Sheindlin is a pretty mean person. Her years on the bench, no-nonsense approach, and arrogance contribute to her abrasive character.

Judge Judy certainly doesn’t hesitate to put people in their place. So next time you find yourself riled up by her antics, remember that there might be more to her than meets the eye.


  • Freya Crawford

    Freya Crawford is a self-confessed geek. She loves gaming, watching classic movies, and her guilty pleasure is trashy reality TV. She also enjoys collecting old NES and Gameboy games.

1 thought on “Why Is Judge Judy So Mean? (8 Reasons Why)”

  1. I have watched judge Judy a bit but it’s not my favorite show, whether it be a judge a lawyer or anyone else they should treat people with respect n courtesy, they are only human beings in a position to help people with there legal problems, if they can’t do that they should be removed from that positions and replaced with someone more capable, n anyone in that type of position shouldn’t use any mind altering alcohol or drug to help them cope with there responsibilities, if they can’t handle there responsibilities without they should be dismissed from that position, they should never ever try to embarrass or talk down to someone to make themselves look smarter n wiser cause most of the time they are not they just want to be abusive to make themselves look important, those kind of people need to spend some time with JESUS CHRIST n learn his attributes on how too treat fellow human beings. ED MILLER


Leave a Comment